The Thunder have turned the Pacers’ ‘organized chaos’ into a hot mess in the NBA Finals

Alonzo Adams-Imagn Images

Indiana’s incredible offense has been thunderstruck by the best defense in the NBA.

The Oklahoma City Thunder are a win away from capping off one of the all-time great seasons in NBA history. Jalen Williams’ 40-point night was the deserved headline grabber in the Thunder’s 120-109 Game 5 win over the Indiana Pacers, but the overarching story of the 2025 NBA Finals has been OKC’s elite defense living up to the hype.

Indiana’s memorable Finals run has primarily been fueled by an electrifying offense that star guard Tyrese Haliburton described as “organized chaos.” They tore through the Eastern Conference while boasting the best (or close to the best) offensive stats across several key categories. While it was never going to be easy against Oklahoma City’s season-long No. 1 rated defense, it was nevertheless intriguing to see how the time-honored championship tradition of an elite offense vs. elite defense would fare.

Spoiler alert: It hasn’t been close.

Indiana has been worse across the board no matter how you slice it.

Stats from NBA.com

The fluidity of the high-volume Pacers passing has been thoroughly disrupted to the point of aimlessness. Their three-point shooting is the worst its been in any of their playoff series. Their ability to get easy buckets in transition has been limited and their turnovers are stressing their transition defense. The lack of a truly dominant scorer is proving itself to be a nearly fatal weakness against a team with Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. Indiana has been able to successfully attack the Thunder in spurts, as evidenced in its Game 1 comeback and the 2nd and 4th quarters of Game 3, but it hasn’t come remotely close to sustaining a full game of success.

Tyrese Haliburton, lauded for his exemplary ability to take care of the ball, entered the NBA Finals with only 31 turnovers through 16 playoff games. He leads all players this series with 20 turnovers over five games. While it’s clear that he’s hobbled with what’s been described as right calf tightness, OKC’s defense has consistently made him extremely uncomfortable. His goose egg in the field goal column made the wrong kind of history in Game 5.

There is no denying that the Thunder defense lives on the edge of the rulebook to the point where it feels like the rules occasionally cease to apply. They are also willing to give up fouls—Lu Dort, Alex Caruso, and Jalen Williams rank 2nd-4th in fouls committed in the Finals—in order to maintain their junkyard dog aggressiveness both on and off the ball. Any hope of another epic Pacers comeback was squashed with a deluge of turnovers forced during OKC’s 21-8 run.

This is not to leave out Chet Holmgren’s shot-altering presence as a seven-footer with Inspector Gadget arms. Efforts by Haliburton and Andrew Nembhard to isolate Holmgren in space and go mismatch hunting at the end of Game 4 proved futile.

And if his prolific scoring wasn’t enough, SGA quietly leads the series in stocks (12 steals + 9 blocks). Not every regular Thunder rotation player is an All-NBA caliber defender, but they are as organized as they are unrelenting.

I’m loath to make the cross-sport comparison given these are the hoopers formerly known as the Seattle SuperSonics, but it’s like watching the prime Legion of Boom Seattle Seahawks on a basketball court. The 2013 Seahawks were both among the league leaders in defensive penalties committed and also number one in turnovers forced and fewest points allowed. They famously took apart Peyton Manning and his juggernaut Denver Broncos offense in the Super Bowl and made it look as if they knew Denver’s offense better than the Broncos did. Of course, the NFL took notice and tightened the rules the ensuing offseason. Oklahoma City has been the best in the regular and postseason in defensive rating and turnovers forced… and have been top-five in fouls committed.

The Pacers have given Thunder everything they can handle through five games of a very entertaining NBA Finals. This series feels over but it’d be wrong to discount a squad that has repeatedly defied the most improbable odds all playoffs. It’s hard to see how they can conjure up the two consecutive wins necessary to vanquish a juggernaut that has flummoxed and flustered their offense to the brink of elimination.